Since the entry into force of Organic Law 1/2025, attempting to resolve certain disputes through an appropriate alternative dispute resolution mechanism —known in Spain as MASC (Medios Adecuados de Solución de Controversias)— has, as a general rule and subject to certain exceptions, become a procedural prerequisite before bringing many civil claims.
This raises a particularly practical question: what happens if one party properly attempts to negotiate, but the other simply does not collect the communication?
Can someone prevent the requirement from being satisfied simply by avoiding the notice and thereby obstruct the other party’s access to the courts?
A recent Order of the Provincial Court of Asturias, dated 18 June 2026, addresses precisely this situation and provides useful guidance on how an attempt to negotiate may be evidenced.
The conclusion is significant: where the communication is correctly sent to a valid address, delivery is attempted and the recipient has a genuine opportunity to access it but does not collect it, that conduct does not necessarily prevent the procedural requirement from being regarded as satisfied.
What does Spanish law require before bringing a claim?
Organic Law 1/2025 introduced an important change to civil litigation in Spain.
As a general rule, before commencing court proceedings, the parties must first have attempted a negotiation aimed at reaching an out-of-court resolution.
The legislation allows different mechanisms to be used, including direct negotiation between the parties or their lawyers, mediation, conciliation, a confidential binding offer and other appropriate dispute resolution methods.
However, it is not enough simply to state in the claim that negotiations were attempted.
The attempt must be capable of being proved.
Where no neutral third party is involved, the legislation allows compliance to be evidenced through documentation showing, among other matters, that the other party received the request or invitation to negotiate —or had an opportunity to access it—, when the communication took place and what it contained.
The way in which the pre-action communication is made and documented therefore becomes crucial.
The case: the recipient did not collect the postal communication
The case considered by the Provincial Court of Asturias arose after a lower court initially refused to admit an application for payment proceedings because it considered that the procedural prerequisite had not been properly evidenced.
Before going to court, the claimant had sent the future defendant a communication inviting her to enter into negotiations.
The notice was sent to the address stated in the contract between the parties.
The postal service attempted delivery. As the recipient was not present, a notice was left informing her that the communication could be collected from the post office.
However, she did not collect it within the relevant period.
The issue was therefore straightforward:
Can the negotiation requirement be considered satisfied if the other party never physically collects the communication?
In the circumstances of the case, the Provincial Court answered yes.
Failing to collect a communication is not the same as sending it to the wrong address
This is probably the most important distinction in the decision.
The Court did not suggest that merely proving that a letter was sent will always be enough.
The party seeking to prove compliance with the MASC requirement should use a method that adequately evidences the communication and the recipient’s ability to access the proposal.
There is, however, an important difference between two situations.
The communication is correctly sent, but the recipient does not collect it
In the case examined:
-
the contractual address was used;
-
delivery was attempted;
-
the recipient was absent;
-
a collection notice was left;
-
and the communication remained available for collection.
The lack of actual receipt was therefore not caused by an error on the part of the person seeking to negotiate.
The recipient had been given a genuine opportunity to access the communication, but did not do so.
For the Provincial Court, that was sufficient to treat the attempt to negotiate as effective.
The communication cannot be delivered because the address is incorrect or unknown
The position may be different where delivery fails because:
-
the address is incorrect;
-
the recipient is unknown at that address;
-
the person has moved;
-
or there is some other circumstance suggesting that the communication never genuinely reached the recipient’s sphere of control.
In those situations, the procedural prerequisite should not automatically be regarded as satisfied merely because there is proof that something was sent.
The distinction is important: it is one thing for a recipient to have the opportunity to access a communication and choose not to do so, and another for that person never to have had a realistic opportunity to become aware of it.
Can someone avoid a MASC simply by ignoring communications?
The purpose of the legislation cannot be to allow one party to indefinitely block access to the courts by refusing to engage in the negotiation process.
The obligation is to make a genuine attempt to resolve the dispute out of court, not to force the other party to negotiate.
Accordingly, a failure to respond, a refusal to participate or certain forms of avoidance do not necessarily mean that the party who properly initiated the MASC process must continue trying indefinitely.
The key issue will be whether it can be shown that there was a genuine attempt to negotiate and that the other party had an effective opportunity to participate.
In the Asturias case, the Court concluded that the claimant had properly made that attempt and that the lack of actual receipt could not be attributed to her.
As a result, the decision refusing admission of the claim was overturned.
Proof of sending alone may not be enough
The decision also contains an important practical lesson for businesses and individuals preparing to bring a claim.
Sending an email, letter or burofax should not be treated as a purely administrative formality.
If compliance with the MASC requirement is later challenged, it may be necessary to prove what was sent, when it was sent, where it was sent and what happened to the communication.
It is therefore advisable to use methods that allow evidence to be retained of:
-
the identity of the sender and recipient;
-
the address or means of communication used;
-
the date of sending;
-
the delivery attempt or completed delivery;
-
the full contents of the communication;
-
and, where possible, receipt or availability of the notice to the recipient.
This documentation may prove decisive if the court later questions whether the procedural requirement was properly satisfied.
What should an invitation to negotiate contain?
Another potential mistake is to assume that any pre-action demand automatically qualifies as a MASC.
The negotiation should concern the same essential subject matter that is later intended to be brought before the court.
The communication should also demonstrate a genuine willingness to attempt an out-of-court resolution.
It should not simply amount to a demand for performance accompanied by an immediate threat of litigation.
The exact content will depend on the dispute and the MASC mechanism chosen, but it should generally make it possible to identify clearly:
-
the dispute in question;
-
the matter to be negotiated;
-
the parties involved;
-
and the fact that there is a genuine invitation to attempt an out-of-court resolution.
Preparing this communication properly from the outset can help avoid procedural problems later.
How long must you wait if the other party does not respond?
Organic Law 1/2025 also regulates when an attempt to negotiate may be considered concluded without agreement.
As a general rule, where the other party receives the initial request to negotiate and 30 calendar days pass without a first meeting or contact aimed at reaching an agreement and without any written response, the negotiation may be treated as having ended without agreement.
There are, however, specific rules depending on the MASC mechanism used and on how the negotiation develops.
For that reason, the same deadline should not automatically be applied to every type of communication without first identifying which form of MASC is being used.
What if I do not know the address of the person I want to sue?
This is a different situation.
Spanish procedural legislation recognises that a claimant may genuinely not know the address or means by which the future defendant can be contacted.
Where that is the case, the impossibility of carrying out the prior communication must be properly justified in accordance with the applicable legal requirements.
This is not the same as sending a notice to an uncertain address and then assuming that the requirement has been fulfilled simply because delivery failed.
The diligence used to locate and contact the other party may become particularly relevant.
What happens if the MASC requirement is not properly evidenced?
The consequence may be significant: the claim may face a procedural obstacle before the court even considers the merits of the dispute.
That is precisely what initially happened in the case examined by the Provincial Court of Asturias.
The lower court considered the evidence insufficient and refused to admit the application.
An appeal was required before the Provincial Court concluded that the communication had given the recipient a genuine opportunity to negotiate and that the requirement should therefore be considered satisfied.
Properly preparing the MASC process can help avoid this type of procedural dispute, as well as the delays and additional costs that may follow.
Evidence of pre-action negotiation has become a key procedural issue
Since the implementation of Organic Law 1/2025, it is no longer enough to ask whether negotiations were attempted.
It is also necessary to ask:
Will we be able to prove it before the court?
Order 180/2026 of the Provincial Court of Asturias provides a useful approach: where the negotiation attempt is correctly sent to the contractual address, delivery is attempted and the recipient has an effective opportunity to collect the communication, that person’s failure to act should not necessarily prejudice the party that complied diligently with its obligations.
However, the decision does not mean that every undelivered communication will be sufficient.
The reason for non-delivery, the address used, the means of communication, the content of the invitation and the evidence retained may all materially affect the outcome.
It is also important to note that this is a decision of a Provincial Court, not binding case law established by the Spanish Supreme Court. The practical interpretation of Organic Law 1/2025 continues to develop, and different courts may adopt nuanced approaches.
For that reason, the MASC requirement should not be treated as a mere procedural formality before litigation, but as a legal stage that should be carefully designed and documented from the outset.
At Solium Legal, we advise individuals and businesses on dispute prevention and resolution, including pre-action negotiations, MASC procedures and civil and commercial litigation.





